Commissioner calls for more transparency on National Sports School admissions process

Published November 16, 2026

Commissioner calls for more transparency on National Sports School admissions process

Published November 16, 2026

The Complaint

The parents of an 11-year-old boy complained to the Office of the Ombudsman about the process used for admission to the National Sports School for the 2025/26 scholastic year.

Their son had applied, with judo as his sporting discipline. Four applicants took part in the selection process, and all obtained a pass. However, the parents subsequently learned that only two places had been allocated to judo.

Their son achieved the same final score as another applicant who was ranked second. However, following the application of an additional formula used by the Admissions Board, he was not admitted.

The parents raised concerns about the transparency of the process. Despite repeated requests, they were not provided with the Standing Operating Procedure (SOP) governing admissions, nor could they find it publicly available. They also maintained that there was no clear information on how quotas for different sporting disciplines were determined.

They further questioned the Wild Card mechanism. According to the complainants, this process was only communicated after the final results had been published. Of the 48 available places, 44 were filled through the main selection process and four were reserved for Wild Cards. The parents said that this arrangement had not been explained beforehand.

Their son was initially informed that he was eligible for the Wild Card process because he was on the waiting list. He was subsequently excluded because of a requirement to obtain at least 90 marks in the physical test, a criterion which the parents maintained had not previously been communicated.

The parents also raised concerns about the presence of local judo instructors during the assessment process, including the instructors of applicants who were eventually selected.

Facts and Findings

The Commissioner for Education, Chief Justice Emeritus Vincent De Gaetano, examined the selection procedures, the Ministry’s response and an internal investigation carried out by the Ministry’s Internal Audit and Compliance Unit (IACU).

The IACU did not question the marks awarded to the applicants but identified shortcomings in the admissions process. It recommended the development of comprehensive marking criteria, their inclusion in a Selection Process Policy and SOP, and publication of the selection criteria in advance for applicants and their parents.

The Commissioner noted that the central concern remained the lack of transparency. Although the relevant SOP was provided to the Office of the Ombudsman during the investigation, it had not been provided to the parents despite their repeated requests.

The investigation also found that neither the Ministry’s initial response nor the IACU report adequately explained the Wild Card mechanism, why four places were reserved for this process, or how quotas for individual sporting disciplines were established. The SOP supplied to the Commissioner did not clarify these matters either.

Similar concerns arose over the waiting-list procedure. The Ministry described this as an “established procedure”, but the Commissioner questioned how a procedure could properly be regarded as established when it was not publicly available and parents had no way of knowing how it operated.

The Commissioner also looked at the presence of local coaches during the judo assessment. The Ministry maintained that they were present for safety purposes and that the assessment was carried out solely by an independent foreign expert.

The Commissioner considered that, irrespective of whether the coaches actually influenced the assessment, their presence created a legitimate concern about the appearance of impartiality. Public confidence in the integrity and independence of the assessment process had therefore been undermined.

The investigation further found that information about the admissions structure had been provided to the parents only in fragments. Their son had obtained the same final mark as another applicant, but an additional formula was then applied which resulted in his exclusion. A further fitness threshold was later applied during the Wild Card process, although applicants scoring below that threshold had previously been admitted through the main process.

The Commissioner concluded that the rules appeared to have been developed during the course of the admissions process, to the detriment of the complainants’ son.

Conclusion and Recommendation

The Commissioner for Education sustained the complaint in full.

He concluded that the assessment process applied to the complainants’ son was unjust and improperly discriminatory in terms of Article 22(1)(a) of the Ombudsman Act. He also found that sufficiently clear and complete reasons had not been provided in time concerning the exercise of discretionary powers in the admissions process.

While acknowledging the recommendations already made by the Ministry’s Internal Audit and Compliance Unit, the Commissioner recommended that these be strengthened to ensure that the National Sports School admissions process is fully transparent in all its details.

In particular, the Commissioner recommended that local coaches or sporting organisations should neither have, nor be perceived to have, the possibility of influencing the admission of applicants.

He further recommended that questions raised by parents about the admissions process, or about the assessment of their sons or daughters, should be answered fully, transparently and in real time.

The Commissioner’s report is being published in the public interest in accordance with Article 29(2) of the Ombudsman Act.

Documents